Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5598112-20170830223755/@comment-25150955-20170913012821

TheFoxyRiolu's Semifinals Week 2 Performance Rankings Are you sure we can't have a Top 12 again?...no...?

2. Celine Tam] Sigh. Look, I know how this is going to end: she'll be in the finals. That said, even though she's young and certainly talented, Mel hit it right on the head for the second time: this wasn't good. It wasn't a good song choice, and she didn't kill it, which would normally make up for it. Maybe I'm being a little too cynical and she WON'T pass through (cause...well, it happened with Angelina Green...), but I doubt it.

1. Colin Cloud What the heck just happened? It's questionable how staged this was, but Colin actually proved himself to be a contender tonight. He completely stepped it up, and his showmanship improved with the act. Does this mean we'll actually get a magician in the finale? It's certainly possible now, considering how much Cloud stepped it up.

''These rankings are being posted live! So this is currently unfinished.''