Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-25433488-20180801203308/@comment-36158916-20180802012953

FandumbUs3r wrote: JoeKerr107 wrote: Opinions on the judges

Simon :

Pros: Tends to give actually constructive criticism and in the previous seasons, he would buzz acts he genuinely didn't like.

Cons: Way too much control on the show, stopping singing acts for no reason, can be incredibly biased towards certain acts especially singers

Heidi:

Pros: Acts in a respectful manner even towards acts that she doesn't like.

Cons: I really can't say anything other than she doesn't like some of the acts that I like lol. Also do the hand-binoculars count

Mel:

Pros: She likes Lioz and Oliver....

Cons: Acts generally rude and condescending towards acts she doesn't like, rarely constructive, biased towards hot guys, all around annoying. She wasn't this bad in earlier seasons tbh.

Howie:

Pros: Seems to recognize what's talent and what's not, acts respectful towards the acts but is also honest, makes some pretty funny comments every now and then, likeable guy

Cons: Can be a little annoying at times when he repeatedly keeps telling the viewers TO VOTE.

So honestly I think Howie and Heidi deserve to stay. Simon can be a good judge but he needs to stop overproducing the show. Mel just seems to have an attitude problem and needs to go.

I agree with you for the most part, but I can think of a better pro for Mel B. It is fun to see an act go after her to scare or humiliate her. I remember how Mike Super and Tape Face used her in past seasons. In this season, the Sacred Riana is targeting her. Yeah ikr, that's one of the reasons I'm rooting for her.