Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-29775574-20180916020206/@comment-32239636-20190524183028

MikeyIsBae wrote: I was thinking about this for the past few days. Has AGT ever had a true, showstopping, shock elimination? Mike and I were talking today about some of Dancing With The Stars and American Idols worst eliminations, but I couldnt think of any eliminations on AGT that were as bad as the ones that happend on those shows. I would say Jackie Evancho and Siro-A are the only two that come to mind with the word shocking elimination. Sure, Courtney not placing in the Top 5 was shocking but the amount of dislikes her youtube videos got and her semifinals performance justified that, and many people saw it coming. Yeah, Idol is infamous for shocking eliminations. I can think of a huge one for almost every single season.