Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5598112-20180726182437/@comment-29762141-20180801201915

Curious Poker Chip wrote: Cardinals111 wrote: Chrisburr wrote:

TheSnuggleKinz wrote: MegaMan775 wrote:  I'd love to see Neil Patrick Harris and Reba McEntire as permanent judges. Maybe even Louis Tomlinson (but that's unlikely since he's doing X Factor UK iirc). Also, this is probably a long shot but Howard Stern coming back would be amazing. Literally no one will agree with this, '''but Howard Stern coming back would be awful. ''' Actually I agree with you on this, ever sinced he robbed Freckled Sky in favor of two crap acts, i have never wanted him back. I definitely agree with you on this! After he did that I had no more use for him! Ridiculous how some people don't want the best judge the show has ever had back over one bad decision when the current judges have made hundreds. I agree. Some people just don't want Piers to come back. I liked Howard alot as a judge until season 10 (Worst Season ever and worst finals ever), then thats where it started going downhill, had he never ROBBED Freckled Sky in the first place, then i could maybe see him as a guest judge!

Piers was the worst as a permanant judge! Too Harsh!

As a Guest Judge though he wasnt near as Bad!

But he did have a heck of a Golden Buzzer who should have won!