Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-10812216-20180908151649/@comment-26471969-20180912164603

Saf95 wrote: Wiseguy1 wrote: Saf95 wrote: Would anyone say this was the weakest semifinal ever? in paper,  Monday night I would had said "hardest to predict if everyone brings their A game"

Wednesday Morning I say "too many acts brought B, C and D game instead of THEIR A game" ( measuring from what we expect to be their best, not necesseraly comparing each other ............only A game were BKJ, Grace and Daniel, Courtney and ACC brought their B game, maybe also Crow................. IMO Vicki, Christina and we 3 were C game, Noah was between C- and D+ game and Da Republik was D game ( no F game though from anyone )

is still hard to predict results tonight AFTER the likely top 3 (  Grace, Courtney and BKJ and all 3 are guaranteed to be at least Dunkin' save ) and 2 of the bottom 5 ( Noah and Da Republik ) Out of curiosity were there any live show performances this season that you would consider their F game? closest to that ( again comparing to what we expect from the act, not comparing acts to each other ) was Da Republik even if technically was good, it was just bland to past performances, even Human Fountain which I heavily dislike actually did not do an F game on the quartefinals but was (for them ) a B game performance ( technically was their best but was grosser to audition performance and thus I say B compared to their audition IMO )