Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5598112-20190829012320/@comment-33029617-20190830003510

TyberZannxxxx wrote: RedWhaley14 wrote:

Saf95 wrote: RedWhaley14 wrote: TyberZannxxxx wrote: Penniezcent wrote: Why do so many people think/want Charlotte? She’s not that good. It should be Bir getting the wildcard really.

I’m seeing Kodi, Eric and LBK for top 3, Tyler as DS, and Greg/Messoudi/Benicio vs Greg/Messoudi/Benicio in the judges choice. Are you sure? I think Charlotte deserves a second chance. So did Verba, but they never got that chance. Also MacKenzie deserves a second chance a lot more in my opinion. Verba would have been a much better wildcard than Ansley or The Sentimentalists. I don't know why they weren't brought back Even if they HAD to bring back a singer, they should've brought back a better one like Damiyr or Callie Day. Charlotte would make more sense though, as she was initially expected to advance to the semifinals, and many people (like me) are heartbroken that the judges sent her home. Usually the Semi's wildcard is a non-singing act. Season 10 was Metal Mulisha Fitz Army, Season 11 was The Passing Zone, Season 12 was The Pompeyo Family, and Season 13 was Front Pictures. I know this season has broken a lot of trends (the lack of an auto-pass, a leaked act in JC not making it, etc) but I'm pretty sure AGT will favor variety over singing because there's almost as many singing acts as there are regular acts.