Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-36491208-20190806224302/@comment-36204591-20190810015011

MegaMan775 wrote: Freshlysqueezed7 wrote: I don’t agree that this is the best lineup AGT has ever had. Howard, Heidi, Mel B, Howie, and Nick was by FAR the best lineup in the history of AGT. So pretty much seasons 8-10. Hard disagree. Mel and Heidi were both horrible judges and got consistently more annoying over time, especially Mel. Gabrielle and Julianne at least seem solid so far I liked Mel and Heidi in seasons 8-10 which is why that was my favorite line up. Heidi starting getting a little annoying in season 11 and Mel in season 12.