Board Thread:Fantasy Seasons/@comment-36204591-20191013224758/@comment-25150955-20191020153420

Oh, yeah, so I think that the rule we should establish for this season is that any No or Buzz we give should be justified. We should have a good reason to give those out; I’ve been in more than one season with a judge who just did not know how to buzz or say no to acts in a fair manner.

That said, here are my justifications!
 * I already explained my general apathy towards Bars & Melody earlier; I don’t think I need to repeat myself.
 * DJ Arch Jnr is wayyy too young for this competition. I still genuinely could not tell you why he’s been on so many Got Talents; there’s no way he told his dad he wanted to be on South Africa’s Got Talent when he was 3 years old. Oh, yeah, and I’m not huge on DJs on these shows as a whole.
 * I actually LOVED Bad Salsa’s BGT performance, but the one picked for their audition wasn’t great. Just kinda felt like above the “mediocre salsa kids” tier. That’s perfectly fine and all, but this doesn’t feel like a “Champions” Performance. If they can improve later, though, I’m all for their advancement.
 * So with Detroit Youth Choir, I’m judging this season not as a regular season, but as a “Champions” season. If the act doesn’t feel like that of a true “Champion”, than I can’t say I’m interested in their participation. I like DYC, I genuinely do, but I don’t think they fit in this kind of season.
 * I’ve never liked Boogie Storm. They’re average dancers with a gimmick that got old quickly. Sorry.