Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-1650307-20160917035243/@comment-25150955-20160917200025

Curious Poker Chip wrote: I don't know what the rules are. The Passing Zone advanced to the finals in season one and was able to audition again in this year. Leonid the Magnificent made the Wild-Card round in season one and was able to audition again... twice! I thought it was strictly the American Idol rules that if you made it to the round where the public votes you can't come back, but apparently not?

Alex Boye should come back because he is a total star in every possible way and he was robbed in Season 10. I can name quite a few acts in Season 10 that were robbed, though I do agree Alex Boyé was the worst elimination out of the acts, he was amazing.

In that same category was Stacey Kay, Scott Heierman (he did slip up but he deserves to return nonetheless), Aiden Sinclair, Aaron Smyth, Semeneya, and Vox. I'd be fine seeing any of them come back next season.