Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5598112-20180830010529/@comment-26471969-20180904021222

for me going from a rating of 1 to 10 ( and I do not believe generally on giving a perfect 10 ) and based on THEIR JUDGING and not whether I like their personality outside of AGT judging  or not
 * Simon Cowell 9 sometimes his criticism is helpful, sometimes is a pain
 * Heidi Klum 9 sometimes she is too sweet or feels out of the loop, but like her positivity
 * Howie Mandel 9.5 in general I like him best, but a few times he goes too corny with his jokes
 * Mel B 8.5 sometimes she does not play into the act, takes everything too seriously. and her moods sometimes affects her judging, but she si full of Energy
 * Howard Stern 8.5 he is okay in his judging, but a few times I cringed on the acts he favored
 * Sharon Osbourne 8 and only because she was a little bland in AGT, but I think after seeing her in X-factor and other TV programs, she would get higher rating if she came back
 * Brandy Norwood only 1 season, but I actually think she would had been very good if it had not been because of the incidents that year that caused her not to continue, she actually cared about what the acts brought, so I will say she was a 8.5 and could had been a 9 in her  2nd season
 * David Hasselhoff 8 and only because while in AGT he seemed to be in a state of "sigh, I have to be here" but from time to time he was fun and insightful
 * Piers Morgan 7.5  sometimes his judging was allright, but sometimes we went WTHeck!, and way he spoke to the acts sometimes felt as a bad taste. Thus reason IMO he is lowest rating