Board Thread:General Discussion/@comment-5598112-20180830010529/@comment-26471969-20180905141358

I do not think simon hates FP

in an impartial and fair perspective

yesterday FP had a wonderful imaging but in the "artistic interpretation" and how it pulled the attention and interest of the audience, it was far shorter than their audition ( storywise their best ) and their QF ( best combination of story and tech )

Simon found it a "confusing storyline" without any sense and thus the X and was not related to the technical point of view, and even thought Mel stood up, she along ( despised what she said while commenting on them ) with Howie also found it confusing, Heidi was only one who saw it 100% as "magical"

I think it is very likely the judges had a hard time deciding between FP and Mochi and discussed it for a while, and we do not have any idea if Riana asked not to be considered