Natasha Le was brought back for the Wild Card Show because she finished in second place in America's vote in Week 2. Her performance in Episode 112 consisted of playing a classical song and "Shake Baby Shake" on the piano. She also briefly sang. Although Piers Morgan gave Natasha an "X" vote, Brandy Norwood and David Hasselhoff both gave her "✓" votes. Natasha did not receive enough votes to finish in at least second place in America's Vote, eliminating her from the competition in Episode 113 again instead of David & Dania - Quick Change and Nathan Burton.