- Italics indicate that the act was either chosen to move on or eliminated in the Judges' Choice, which means they finished in either seventh or eighth in America's Vote.
From the 36 Quarterfinalists, 12 acts performed each week over three weeks. Each week, 7 acts moved onto the Semifinals.
The contestants that came in sixth, seventh, and eighth place in America's Vote fight for votes online in the Dunkin' Save. The act who received the most votes earned a spot in the Semifinals. The judges voted between the two remaining acts the last spot of the week in the semifinals.
- 3. Angel City Chorale, Choir (Dunkin' Save)
- 5. Amanda Mena, Singer
- 6. Junior New System, Dance Group
- 7. We Three, Band
- 10. Shin Lim, Magician
- 11. Vicki Barbolak, Stand-up Comedienne
- 12. Courtney Hadwin, Singer/Dancer
- 1. Mochi, Multimedia Juggler
- 2. Human Fountains, Novelty Act
- 4. The PAC Dance Team, Dance Group
- 8. Lord Nil, Escape Artist
- 9. Flau'jae, Rapper
- 1. Makayla Phillips, Singer (Dunkin Save)
- 2. Da RepubliK, Dance Group
- 3. Noah Guthrie, Singer/Guitarist
- 5. Samuel J. Comroe, Stand-up Comedian
- 6. Voices of Hope Children's Choir, Choir
- 8. Glennis Grace, Singer
- 12. Duo Transcend, Trapeze Duo
- 4. Yumbo Dump, Comedy Duo
- 7. The Savitsky Cats, Cat Act
- 9. The Sacred Riana, Illusionist
- 10. Quin and Misha, Ballroom Dance Duo
- 11. Front Pictures, Multimedia Performance Act
- 2. Us the Duo, Band
- 3. Daniel Emmet, Opera Singer (Dunkin Save)
- 4. Brian King Joseph, Electric Violinist
- 5. Aaron Crow, Danger Act
- 9. Christina Wells, Singer
- 10. Zurcaroh, Acrobatic Group
- 12. Michael Ketterer, Singer
- 1. The Future Kingz, Dance Group
- 6. Joseph O'Brien, Singer/Pianist
- 7. Hans, Singer/Dancer/Pianist/Accordionist
- 8. UDI, Blacklight Group
- 11. Rob Lake, Magician
The judges chose Front Pictures as their single Wild Card pick, allowing it to return to the competition in the Semifinals.
- Front Pictures, Multimedia Performance Act
- This is the first time that 2 Golden Buzzers were eliminated before the Semifinals.
- This is also the first time that 2 Golden Buzzers were eliminated in the Bottom 4.
- This is the first time since Metal Mulisha Fitz Army that an act was a double wildcard.
- This is the first time that all Golden Buzzers from the auditions made it past the Quarterfinals.