Shadow Dancing's audition in Episode 101 consisted of performing a story about pirates and a pony involved in a love triangle. The judges could not understand the performance. Instead of voting, the judges agreed to have the audience vote. The also confused audience booed, eliminating the act from the competition.
America's got talent season 1 episode 1 part 2.avi
Shadow Dancing was the first act to be rejected from the next round despite not being buzzed.
It was the first act whose fate was decided by the audience instead of a vote.